6 Comments

Jesus, you can see the reservations.

Expand full comment

Yes these are very clearly visible in the Dakotas and south west.

Expand full comment

Thank you for highlighting the current trend in smoking rates and the very helpful round up of policies that have been successful in reducing smoking rates.

One of my parents tried many times over the years to quit smoking, and I really pressed the matter when my son was diagnosed with asthma and visits to their house were clearly aggravating his condition. Despite an attempt to quit again, they went back to smoking.

It was only when the state (MN) implemented a cigarette tax of about $1.50 per pack (it subsequently has been increased again I think) that my parent was FINALLY properly motivated enough to quit, because they couldn't stand the idea of paying all that extra tax to the government. :P

Of course my siblings and I tried to get them to think about the cost of smoking many times over the years... that they were basically burning up $30,000 a decade that might have been spend on other things, but it's only when Uncle Sam would get the money, instead of RJ Reynolds that it was too much an injustice to bear. ;)

Expand full comment

Thanks so much for sharing your story Crystal. This is such a powerful example of many pieces covered in the story - the impact of smoking on health in the household (i.e. your son's asthma); how people respond to incentives (i.e. Minnesota's cigarette tax encourages them to quite); and the overall role that families end up having to play in battling with smoking issues (i.e. you being the one having to convince your parents).

Expand full comment

... thank you so much for that exhaustive inclusive outstanding report. I worked in cancer at the veterans hospital, where I learned that during WW II as far as I know and perhaps WWI : small packs of four cigarettes were in each GIs food kit, each meal. Government taught a generation of youth to smoke... being a boomer myself,

I had my first cigarette at 13 making me desperately ill and asking for another one the next day. My brother has died of lung cancer , mother died of lung cancer; I have had two cancer so we are cancer candidates --but I have not hit lung yet---perhaps I should have the new scan.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Oct 25, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Imagine wishing death on people you disagree with and thinking you’re a good person. Every one is smoking more because Biden is overseeing a terrible economy, rising crime, and escalating forwards world war 3.

Expand full comment